Chair Reupholstery: Choosing Fabric

I’ve been looking for some modern wing chairs for our living room for awhile.  Not too tall, not too wide, but cozy enough to read by the fire during the rainy winter here in Portland.

Then last week, I found the perfect pair of vintage wing chairs on Etsy at LivenUPdesign!  Plus, Jenn, the shop owner, included custom reupholstering in the price.  Done and done.

And then…hours and hours of looking at fabric.  So much fabric to love!

I narrowed my choices down to a soft velvet for the seat cushions, and a great print for the back.  Here are the three finalists.  What would you pick?

Fabrics:  dark grey velvet, eagle print, blue velvet, robshaw print, grey fabric, red print